Group Hero

Money & Investing

219,823 members

From personal finance tips to halal investment strategies, we're here to help you navigate the world of money 💸 Muzz takes no responsibility for the accuracy or uptake of financial advice shared in this group.

Share group
El Ana

@Elana

7 days ago

Looking for two Pomeranian puppies

8 Likes
3
Share
Jade

@BasicJade

8 days ago

Let’s Talk About MSCI: Are We Really That Broke That We Should Be Compared to Zimbabwe?

I think we need to look at this situation with a clearer head.

  1. The issue is bigger than market performance. It is also about Indonesia’s credibility and standing in the global investment community. MSCI’s proposal to reclassify Indonesia from Emerging Market to Standalone Market status is a serious signal for international investors. But this is a market classification, not a verdict on Indonesia’s economic wealth.

  2. This raises questions about institutional engagement and the assessment process. Indonesia has announced reforms addressing MSCI’s concerns, including greater shareholder transparency and improved free-float disclosure. Yet MSCI says implementation and its impact remain insufficient. The question is whether the remaining gaps have been communicated clearly enough for the authorities to address them effectively, especially given the market reaction and the Indonesian authorities’ request for clarification.

  3. The market impact raises serious questions. Following MSCI’s proposed reclassification, the IHSG fell 11.57% on 16 October 2026 and closed below 5,000 at 4,996.61 on 19 October. Meanwhile, the MSCI Indonesia Index has shrunk from 18 constituents at the beginning of the year to just nine. These figures demonstrate the scale of the market pressure. While market movements cannot be attributed to MSCI alone, the timing and consequences of its decisions deserve careful scrutiny.

  4. There may also be interests that could benefit from this uncertainty. I would not jump to conclusions about anyone’s motives without evidence. However, when a decision by a major index provider can trigger substantial market volatility and influence international investment flows, we should remain alert to how others might exploit the situation to shape narratives or advance their own interests.

Reference: Reuters, MSCI’s case against Indonesian stocks and the $65 billion fallout.

https://www.marketscreener.com/news/msci-s-case-against-indonesian-stocks-and-the-65-billion-fallout-ce785cdbd980f126

5 Likes
2
Share
Goldie247

@Goldie24_7

9 days ago

Markets getting smashed 👍

7 Likes
22
Share
Anonymous

9 days ago

What do you guys think of Micron? Wait to buy it this the cheapest it will be

3 Likes
5
Share
Aline

@aline06

9 days ago

Hi everyone,
I work in a property company, if you are looking for a property, hit me up plz. I will send you an invitation to come to the sales center.

10 Likes
6
Share
Anonymous

10 days ago

Assalamu alaikum
Anyone investing on EFT? How do you make sure all the companies in that EFT is halal? What app do you use? Thanks. I have little spare money at the end of the month. I may have to start just with €100

Experts please guide me. Thanks a lot!

6 Likes
13
Share